There was a good discussion on here a few months ago. I did quite a bit of research on lighting and the biggest factor seemed to be PAR (Photosynthetic Activity Radiation). Not lumens, not watts, but how much of a light sprectrum is used by the plants.
The mulches (or plastics) are supposed to play a factor but realistically have very little effect once the plant gets very big, unless it is isolated. I used the red plastic this summer but because I didn't have acres of room to spare, after a few weeks, it was shaded by foliage, so very little light was reflected/absorbed. (A side note - white plastic is supposed to be great for potatoes, as it directs light that encourage root growth, or something like that!).
If you can do a Google search for NASA, plant growth, PAR and similar terms, you should be able to come across a very in-depth article about the merits of different lights, though NASA considered energy usage as a high priority. The study related to colonizing Mars, where growing food would be key to survival, since it would cost too much to ship them a care package every month.
Mike